magura mt trail sport vs shimano xt

They're very good brakes, and for 80 USD a wheel I won't be surprised to see a lot more on the streets and trails. Good power, nice lever feel, but a bit on/off. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Excellent modulation and raw stopping power. You must log in or register to reply here. Having tried the MT7 race pads, the performance pads definitely feel like they have less bite and a bit less power, however they were definitely more usable in more trail situations where I preferred the less grabby feel. Then the 4+2 piston MT Trail SL system came along and combined a 6 & 7, the MT Trail Sport was a lower priced trail hybrid of the 4 & 5, and now there a couple of named brakes at the top and bottom of the line-up. I ride mostly all mountain and trail. XT vs. Magura Trail Sport vs. Formula Cura - Mountain Bike Reviews Forum Each brake was subjected to the same torturous protocol using the manufacturers own 180 mm rotor. It is no measure of health to be well adjusted to a profoundly sick society. Its the little things like this that we really appreciate about Magura. ENDURO Mountainbike Magazine is published in a digital app format in both English and German. Brake pads are not "parts", they better damn be available, or what, you throw out the brake after you wear down some pads? Photo: Jason Lorch. 203mm up front and a 180mm at the rear. Min-Max, The1-finger HC aluminium lever bladehas been ergonomically optimised and is now also suitable for riders with somewhat smaller hands. Hardtails pull no punches when it comes to trail feedback and we certainly felt the sensitivity of the braking due to the lack of rear suspension softening the effect. It felt like there was too much, I expected similar power from other 2 piston brakes on the market. About 60-80% of the control and stopping power comes from our front brake. Punching in as Magura's lowest-priced brake is this MT Trail at 80 USD per wheel. Magura MT 7 Pro brakes review - BikeRadar Magura MT Trail sport The World's largest electric mountain bike community. It's also lighter than the XT. I bleed my own brakes and recently didn't do the best job. Iniciar sesin; Crear una cuenta; Bienvenido, Iniciar sesin o Crear una cuenta. @2020 - All Right Reserved Tyres and Soles. Due to aluminium levers instead of carbon, Magura has been able to drop the price of this exceptional brake package significantly, passing these benefits onto you, the rider. Magura ships the MT Trail with their longest lasting, lowest friction, pad compound called the 'Comfort' model. Hands down best stopping power Ive ever experienced. Apparently they are a bitch to bleed though. You could get a bleed kit and do it yourself, and maybe put in metallic pads. Continental Der Baron Projekt and Trail King ProTection Apex Combo Review, IXS Flow EVO+ Knee Pads Long Term Review. Frenos Magura MT4 Flatmount para uso MTB, vlido para freno delantero y trasero, aportando gran estabilidad y modulacin. A cycling community enthusiastic about mountain biking and all things related. If your brake is designed to use one system, you cannot switch as your gaskets and seals will be damaged. Les meilleures offres pour Magura Storm Rohloff Disque Frein Rotor 180mm 4-Bolt Argent sont sur eBay Comparez les prix et les spcificits des produits neufs et d 'occasion Pleins d 'articles en livraison gratuite! If I was able to find a replacement MC bladder for my old Hayes 9, I would have just rebuilt it and called it a day. Perches can adapt to SRAM or Shimano direct-mount controls. On the dyno the brakes were bedded in with 20 cycles of 1 second pulls from 15 km/h, then 20 cycles of 2 second pulls from 15 km/h, repeated twice. DVO appreciation and support thread (AKA the Ced Thread) - Pics, ride reports and discussion, The Sexiest AM/FR/Enduro Hardtail Thread (Please read the opening post), Bleeding Disc Brakes for the first time, seeking info, Post Your Road Bikes (Read 1st post for guide), Rad retro MTB stuff [MTB of any discipline], SantaCruz Bikes up to 25% off & NO SALES TAX at Owenhouse Bikes Bozeman Montana, Report Scammers on Pinkbike HERE *Read 1st Post* then contact captainbringdown directly, Crunching 3 easiest gears on Shimano Saint drivetrain. Rain, mud, loam, sweat, fatigue and fear all put demands on brakes, impossible to measure on a machine. All levers were wound out to the maximum and bite point set as far out as possible. You are using an out of date browser. Shimano really screwed the pooch with the m8000s. Over the last 4 months, our test team has been putting 19 of the leading disc brakes to the test through rain and shineeven a little snow: warped rotors, boiling fluid, glazed pads, there has been nowhere to hide. Come join the discussion about bike parts, components, deals, performance, modifications, classifieds, trails, troubleshooting, maintenance, and more! JavaScript is disabled. Both have 1-finger levers, come with all the bolts&bits, it comes down to quality/functionality I guess. The Trail Sports have a four piston up front. So what are the best shimano 4 pot brakes then? Got XTs on my canyon strive and magura trail sport on my Marin sq, and overall I get the feeling of not having to think that much of breaking when Im on my Marin sq1 with maguras (and thats a good thing, to be clear :)). I've had the shop bleed them twice in 200kms since new. Photo: Jason Lorch, The brake pads are super-easy to replace with the magnetic snap-in system. JavaScript is disabled. We recommend a minimum of 200/180 mm for general riding. Of course the XTs does a good job, and Ive been happy for them until I tried the maguras. learn more The new MAGURA VYRON MDS-V3 The B Practice Podcast crew discusses if adding more points-paying runs per round will water down the intensity of racing due to riders focusing more on consistency and the season overall. Also just switched to a Shigura set up with Deore levers and MT7 calipers. Required fields are marked *, New Parts HAUL! Even on steep sections, the range of modulation allows for much more controlled descending, when needed. No matter how good the levers, or how large the pistons, all the braking forces are transferred by the brake pads onto the discs. Magura MT Trail Sport HC 1-Finger Disc Brake Set MAGURA's new definition of trail braking performance at an affordable price. Ive also found some of the Shimano ZEE 4 pots on Ebay for 230$ or so. (Basically the same brakes except MT4 rear caliper, which if you . MT5 calipers can use both the MT5 MagnetiXchange pads (which used magnets to align and secure themselves to the caliper; no bolts required!) Introducing the new Focus Jam2 and Sam2 your perfect match. Is it the modulation you think better of? Magura MT 5's or Shimano SLX's ? - Pinkbike Forum Born out of experimentation, the Magura riders and employees often mixed and matched Maguras four- and two-piston options to suit their riding style and intended use, so the German brand decided to bring a mismatched setup to market. I am running a MT5 in the front and MT4 on the rear and really love them, even with the stock pads they feel stronger than the Saints they replaced. Magura Trail Sport, I'd suspect you shop is not doing the best job bleeding them. R rsilvers Well-known member Dec 2, 2018 283 242 US Oct 31, 2019 #3 For those who live in the Alps, carry excess weight or simply hunger for brute power, the Magura MT7 and Shimano Saint models are hard to beat for value and power. Quick-Fit Adapters are designed to work with Jagwire Pro Hydraulic Hose The difference between a SRAM Guide and SRAM Code is only about 20-30g, nothing in real world terms, but the Code model is a step up in performance. It may seem crazy but pulling on the rear brake often causes you to skid out of control, and control is what you need when it comes to braking. MSRP is 585 a pair (carbon blades), plus $64 for a pair of 148-gram Storm HC . The 280 USD Trail Sport system can go up against brakes that cost twice as much, including any that Magura makes. Ride one I was begging for more bite and when trails became steep or fast it turned to screams. Now you dont need to overthink your braking, just let the natural braking abilities of the 4 and 2 piston combination to take care of it for you. The same master cylinder I've been using for years on MT 5 and Trail Sport combined with the Carbotecture lever blades I tested this winter. The magura hose inner diameter is bigger so you are pushing more oil than the XT levers usually push. In search of a decent alternative for every time zone, [], The rear uses a 2 piston setup with 4 pistons up front. It hasthe braking power of an MT5 and the modulation of an MT8all at a very competitive price point. Shimano SLX Trail M7120 - Mantel Magura USA Storm HC 6-Bolt Rotor One Color, 203mm. The XTR brakes feel like pretty much every other Shimano brake. Press J to jump to the feed. ie, keep the existing disks and mounts ? The ergonomics of the short HC aluminum lever mean that it can reliably deliver full braking power at the touch of just one finger. New shared architecture Drivetrain components from Shimano. . Interested in experience with the Maguras also. Min-Maxed With The Magura MT Sport - NSMB.com Mechanics Quick Question Thread [Ask Questions Here], Deutschen Fhrerschein kaufen Fhrerschein Klasse B kaufen (https://counterfeitdocument.com), Dirt Jump Bikes. Whether youre a rider that wants an on-the-limit race-tuned performance or just want to feel safer and more secure, the disc brake has to fulfill all those expectations, as well as be reliable, easy to maintain, lightweight and, ideally, affordable. Ensure you tighten the top up to 4nm first and then the bottom to 4nm. MT Trail Sport. $22.99. Entrega GRATIS en 24h! Im having a mid winter dilemma, I am currently building a Kona Honzo st and I am ready to purchase my brakes. Thats what Ive read around and ehy Im considering them even though my usual go-to manufacturer is Shimano. If I need them in a hurry I buy pads from Cove. Magura's MT Trail lever with the new OEM one-finger aluminum lever blade option. A hugely powerful brake with no sensitivity is akin to driving a 1000hp car down a gravel road with no traction control. MAGURAs proven trail concept is a price/performance miracle compared to other brake packages on the market. Some of the brakes would initially deliver high braking torques, but within a second, as the pad heated up, braking torque would fall off dramaticallythis is all due to the efficiency of the pad material. With the Race pads up front and the Comfort pads in the back my MT Trail experience was excellent. The rebuildability of the Formulas is what I find appealing, as well as the good reviews and polished silver color option. But all of that is just a minor difference, you might not even feel. Im a big boy but I can get her done on most sections other than steep climbs hahaha ! Please post them below or check out Magura for more information. I did this wrong and I broke the clamp in a crash, which could have been avoided If I did this properly. But I cant find anywhere locally to test them on a bike so: I have the Maguras and love them. Features, Two-Piston Trail. Magura MT Trail SL Brakeset $593.10 (13) And we are going faster. MAGURA MT: Installation. It has the braking power of an MT5 and the modulation of an MT8 all at a very competitive price point. MT7 for sure. Ergonomic lever blade with smaller hand options. The mixed piston combination provides a powerful braking system. But tell us all about it when you get back. Its good to save weight on a bike, but its where you save weight thats most important. * Magura combines the same injection-molded Carbotecture master cylinder found on the MT Trail Sport setup I've tested previously, and the 4-piston MT 5 brakes that I've owned for years, with a basic 2-piston caliper which, quite remarkably at this price, is still a one-piece unit. magura mt trail sport mt7 mt5; . I think ease of maintenance would go to Shimano. Grab a mate, a partner, a pet and head out into nature. I think you'll be fine with either brake. Shimano Altus BR-MT200 Organische Achterrem (zonder schijf) 170cm Zwart The MT Trail Sport brakes (without rotors) register a respectable 485 grams for the pair. I run 203mm front and 180mm rear. Way more modulation, stopping power, and just as smooth. The MTTS feel a bit less grabby than the XT. I hope you find what youre looking for , I run shiguras. Once these and the spares off the front burn out I'd switch to running Performance. * Magura combines the same injection-molded Carbotecture master cylinder found on the MT Trail Sport setup I've tested previously, and the 4-piston MT 5 brakes that I've owned for years, with a basic 2-piston caliper which, quite remarkably at this price, is still a one-piece unit. There was less rear brake to help skid around some corners and more emphasis on using the front brakes to scrub most of the speed and focusing more on modulating the rear to avoid any unnecessary skidding. Maguras feels better at modulating and feel like they have more power even though theres 180mm rotors on the sq1 and 203mm rotors on the Strive. Riding fast is one of the best feelings: we argue over KOMs in the pub and agonise over reviews telling us we need a bigger wheel size to keep up with our buddies. . Video. I'm able to find all kinds of random parts on eBay. Learn more BMW R18 fittings Powerful, elegant yet with rebellious potential. Shimano SLX BR-M7120 Disc Brake $186.99 (18) Award Winner. The brakes use mineral oil, however it is important to use Maguras own Royal Blood mineral oil, as other brands will damage the lines. The two options im stuck on are Magura MT5s With HC Rotors 203 up front and 180 out back or Shimano M7000 SLX's and 203 RM66 up front . The MT Trail Performance line pads are easily removed via the mounting screw and sliding the pads out through either the top or bottom of the brake. The brakes come stock with Carbotecture clamps. Dont forget aftermarket pads too: in our tests fitting the Trickstuff Power+ brake pads to the SRAM Code R resulted in a 20% improvement in average braking torque, and an average of 18% improvement in deceleration times. Considering each brake as a whole, the task of picking a winner is not an easy one. Gambling on the Retrogrouch - Shimano XT LinkGlide M8130. Added to shopping list and the muppet question .. will these straight swap over on a Mk1 Kenevo Expert ?? No, not really. **front + rear, w/o rotors. First ride review of the Mondraker DUSTY XR 2023 e-gravel bike for trail surfers and adventurers, The 9Barista Espresso Machine Premium espresso to-go, Master Material: Carbotecture, Flip-Flop-Design, Brake Fluid: Royal Blood (mineral oil-based). https://www.ebay.com/itm/Shimano-Di587953&hash=item41f0494eeb:g:ry8AAOSwy~Jbvj3e, https://www.ebay.com/itm/Shimano-BHPpc0mnA:sc:ShippingMethodStandard!93063!US!-1, https://www.ebay.com/itm/Shimano-BHm=302926261752&_trksid=p2047675.c100005.m1851, https://www.thebikeshopstore.com/cayBvX8A_bcLkfJkzyVLtQ0W0fqI4jSomhoCWJEQAvD_BwE, https://www.ebay.com/itm/Metal-Pistm=173843264195&_trksid=p2047675.c100005.m1851, https://forums.mtbr.com/brake-time/formula-cura-brakes-1044842.html, https://forums.mtbr.com/brake-time/magura-mt5-vs-shimano-zee-vs-formula-cura-1093255.html, https://nsmb.com/articles/min-maxed-magura-mt-sport-brakes/, https://enduro-mtb.com/en/best-mtb-disc-brake-can-buy/. It's also lighter than the XT. Only 7 left in stock - order soon. . Want bonus stopping power? Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Photo: Jason Lorch, The levers are super-light and ergonomically designed with lever reach adjustment screws. Go with Magura. The reach adjustment is flush with the lever blade. Lever style may not suit all riders tastes. A small but nice touch. The top of the clamp will be touching the lever body while the bottom isnt. The 203mm front and 180mm rear provide plenty of stopping power. Einfach. 1 set (caliper + lever) of Hope E4 or X2 = 2 sets (caliper + lever) of Magura Trail Sport. eBay Kleinanzeigen: Sattel Sttel, Herrenfahrrad gebraucht kaufen oder verkaufen - Jetzt in Aidlingen finden oder inserieren! The xtr 9000 race has great modulation . Rocky Mountain Growler, Magura MT8 vs XTR M9000 ? While not as ergonomic for me, as their generously hooked aluminum or carbon HC levers, the Trail brakes feature the same Carbotecture Sport blades I ran on my four year old MT 5 system for the winter in my quest to manage issues with cold digits. | Budget Hardtail MTB Build (EP 1), 2022 Norco Bikes MTB Line Up Review (Bikemas Day 14), 2022 Propain Bikes MTB Line Up Review (Bikemas Day 13), 2022 Fezzari Bikes MTB Line Up Review (Bikemas Day 12). I'm also a bit of a muso and enjoy a good craft beer every now and again (probably too often). Magura MT8 vs XTR M9000 ? - Weight Weenies - starbike.com Considering upgrading the XTs to magura mt7 or is there a way to get the XTs to feel a little more like maguras? What is it about the xt levers that is better than maguras? The 30-15 km/h deceleration time is very representative of high-speed riding, and is far more informative a result than the power figures alone. Absolute power values in the lab are meaningless if we apply a force that is unobtainable by a single human finger. Tags: The MT Trail setup we tested came with a pair of Magura Storm HC rotors. Components - Brakes. This is the new Focus Jam2 and Sam2. Magura MT Trail Sport Disc Brake 4yJ8A-m33979159738 - > > ()2~3 ,, . MAGURA's proven trail concept is a price/performance miracle. Photo:Jason Lorch. Compared to full alloy bodies there is slightly more flex with the short levers, however with the 2 finger levers the flex is noticeably more. Magura is half the price of Shimano. I have been using the brakes for about 4 months now, riding about 30km per week and am still using the original pads, which were the performance MagnetiXchange pads. Magura MT Trail Sport - Anyone tried them yet? Which seems to happen more than it should because I always underestimate how fast they wear. Get it as soon as Tuesday, Mar 7. Personally, I found the small bit of lever flex provided a little bit of modulation but as soon as you pressed the lever down hard the blunt force of the brakes can be felt. magura mt trail sport box 2() 34000 [] I generally buy gear from my local shop so cant help you there. They dont feel as touchy as Shimano brakes, which tend to have an on/off feeling but there is a small bit of modulation at the beginning of the stroke, so you dont always scrub off too much speed when a light touch is needed. Do you get a wandering bite point with this setup? We ran the MT Trail Sport brakes on a long-travel 29er hardtail. Magura is cheaper than Hope. I'm interested in peoples experience and opinions in which brakes to upgrade to. Parts for Shimano brakes are pretty common. Oh I got mine from Star Bike very reasonable. The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. Magur MT trail sport vs Shimano Trail sport : r/mountainbiking Bleed kits? The two-piston MT4 variety is on call for skid duty out back. Whisky, riding his bike and everything in between. The air was filled with the smell of hot metal as every parameter was measured, recorded and logged with unflinching accuracy. Does not matter which model as the calipers are the same among models. They're still one piece for added stiffness but they don't use Magura's position-adjustable bolt-on brake line. I've got the Trail Sport and XT brakes (m785). The cura's are some damn nice brakes. I'll check with my local shop, but I don't find the Vic shops carry much Magura stuffso usually easier to get online. and the MT7 pads, which use individual pads per piston, which offer a stronger bite and fade resistance. Initial repeated decelerations leaves a residue of pad material on the disc, permitting maximum friction and performance. It is impossible to push powerful brakes consistently to the limit on the trail. The new Shiftmix 4 handlebar clamp combines a Shimano I-Spec EV shifter and a Magura brake master in a single clamp. Features Min-Maxing, I was even quite happy with rear brake performance combined with a 180mm rotor. The best MTB disc brake you can buy | Page 9 of 20 | ENDURO Magur MT trail sport vs Shimano Trail sport Magura is half the price of Shimano. The XT's lever blades are a bit thinner. I went for a ride on my usually test loop and realised how dependent I had become on my rear break and came into a section way too hot and went over the bars. Any questions? I believe mine are 160mm front and rear. Deccessorization [Forum] MEAT Engines 2023. I've done some looking around and have narrowed it down to two options. Disc temperatures reached over 400 C during this savage test, and fade was evident in most brakes gas produced from hot pad resin decreasing friction. Rob has ridden the bike, so make You must log in or register to reply here. Forget about buying parts. Front pads (left) compared with the rear. Installing new pads is a breeze due to the magnetic design that snap the pads into place. This smooth linear curve offers an impressive range of lever/brake feedback to apply a much higher level of control on the trails. For those who love smooth modulation, then the TRP Quadiem, Hope and SRAM Guide offer the most linear deceleration. This is my setup. Trying to save some money if possible. This makes the tolerances quite tight. As we rolled into steep, often blind, roll downs, the MT Trail Sport provided us with plenty of confidence to slowly creep forward, inch by inch, with total control. The reason it's sold as a set is because you get a more powerful four-piston front brake to do most of the stopping and a two-piston rear to save weight and to improve feel. My hesitation is German engineering, because I've owned a lot of German cars and well.you know. The lever compresses the master cylinder vertically versus horizontally (on the same plane) compared to most brakes (if that makes sense). Then pumping the leaver till the pads meet in the middle. Be aware that the MT7 and MT5 calipers are identical (sans color, obv). Digital & free: The 9Barista Espresso Machine Premium espresso to-go. I just recently switched form XTR trails to 4 pod (polished) Curas and so far have been very happy with the switch. The MT Trail Sport set utilizes the same 42 piston setup at a sliver of the price. I've got 180/180 on my 140mm bike. As a reminder of his new role as a father, the words Think about Brook." Both offer 4-pot front + 2-pot rear caliper. Initially, I was impressed with the ergonomics of the levers. After 4 rides in horrible conditions in Tasmania the brakes never lost bite or became contaminated, however they were noisy but as the weather dried up the noise subsided immediately. Shimano Consolidates Entry- to Mid-Level Groupsets With New CUES Drivetrains, Opinion: Five Things The Bike Industry Could Do Better, Throwback Thursday: A Brief History of Direct Mount Derailleurs, Buying a Bike From a Shop Versus Buying Online, DH Bike Review: Canfield's Jedi Masters Rough Terrain, Review: Mythos 3D-Printed Titanium Stem is My Kind of Excess, DH Bike Review: Orange 279 - A Staple of British Downhill Racing, www.hibike.com/magura-mt-trail-carbon-carbotecture-sl-disc-brakes-set-front-wheel-pm-rear-wheel-pm-left-right-mountable-without-disc-adapter-black-chrome-2017-p2114a624f82cf9d9c28479ee7d28734e, www.bikeradar.com/mtb/gear/category/components/disc-brake-systems/product/magura-mt5-review-51215. This would give us a realistic, not theoretical indication of a brakes power from a firm pull. I was immediately impressed with the front brake, however there was a big discrepancy in power with the rear. There are lots of old-but-good mountain bikes, and entry-level performance mountain bikes out there in need of new binders for a wide variety of reasons. The only brakes i have ever ridden that are anywhere near them are the new hayes 4pots. IMO xt is kinda on/off braking (rough said) and the maguras is more gradually braking. What are you guys impression of the difference between these brakes? Discos de freno Magura MT eStop Flotantes para ebike (180, 203 y 200mm) Born and grew up in Wales but now a fully fledged Aussie. I was wondering if the mdr-p 220mm would fit on the rear of a levo? From the ultimate nightmare to an inspiring recovery. Another plus is that royal blood is touted to be more environmentally friendly compared to competitors. customisable and powerful trail brakes, just be aware of bleeding issues . By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Feel more robust. There is no reason for them to get spongy again unless they are defective. What size rotors are you running? Salomon Sense Ride 2 W Trail Running A happy news story for Hornsby OMV Trails, From the Worst Crash You Can Imagine, Back to Happiness; Tommo's Amazing Recovery. I know there more geared towords Gravity setups but being a big boy and not worried 1 ioda about weight maybe I should run something like that . Ok I bought the ZEEs they seem like the best bang for the buck and I already have a bottle of Shimano fluid and a bleeder tool kit.

Dead Body Found In Whittier Today, Sun Trine North Node Transit, County Durham And Darlington Nhs Foundation Trust Values, Connie Mcburney Obituary, Articles M